| Allegheny Mountain Collegiate Conference |
La Roche (22-5) |
| American Rivers Conference |
Wartburg (25-2) |
| American Southwest Conference |
East Texas Baptist (23-4) |
| Atlantic East Conference |
Immaculata (22-3) |
| Centennial Conference |
Gettysburg (25-2) |
| City University of New York Athletic Conference |
Brooklyn (17-11) |
| Coast-to-Coast Athletic Conference |
Christopher Newport (26-1) |
| College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin |
Illinois Wesleyan (26-1) |
| Collegiate Conference of the South |
Piedmont (20-7) |
| Conference of New England |
Endicott (22-5) |
| Empire 8 |
SUNY Geneseo (22-6) |
| Great Northeast Athletic Conference |
Saint Joseph (Connecticut) (19-9) |
| Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference |
Transylvania (22-5) |
| Landmark Conference |
Scranton (26-1) |
| Liberty League |
Vassar (21-6) |
| Little East Conference |
Massachusetts Dartmouth (23-4) |
| Massachusetts State Collegiate Athletic Conference |
Bridgewater State (19-6) |
| Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association |
Calvin (18-10) |
| Middle Atlantic Conference Commonwealth |
Messiah (25-2) |
| Middle Atlantic Conference Freedom |
Stevens (19-8) |
| Midwest Conference |
Ripon (23-4) |
| Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference |
Gustavus Adolphus (26-1) |
| New England Small College Athletic Conference |
Bowdoin (27-0) |
| New England Women’s & Men’s Athletic Conference |
Smith (26-2) |
| New Jersey Athletic Conference |
Montclair State (23-4) |
| North Atlantic Conference |
SUNY Cobleskill (24-4) |
| North Coast Athletic Conference |
DePauw (20-6) |
| Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference |
Wisconsin Lutheran (21-7) |
| Northwest Conference |
Whitman (26-1) |
| Ohio Athletic Conference |
Baldwin Wallace (26-1) |
| Old Dominion Athletic Conference |
Randolph-Macon (27-1) |
| Presidents’ Athletic Conference |
Washington & Jefferson (23-4) |
| St. Louis Intercollegiate Athletic Conference |
Principia (17-11) |
| Skyline Conference |
Mount Saint Mary (New York) (17-10) |
| Southern Athletic Association |
Centre (21-7) |
| Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference |
Cal Lutheran (22-6) |
| Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference |
Texas Lutheran (23-4) |
| State University of New York Athletic Conference |
Cortland (24-3) |
| United East Conference |
Gallaudet (18-10) |
| University Athletic Association |
New York University (25-0) |
| Upper Midwest Athletic Conference |
Wisconsin-Superior (17-10) |
| USA South Athletic Conference |
Southern Virginia (26-2) |
| Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference |
Wisconsin-Whitewater (22-6) |
